I, Jeanie and our boys, Jay and Jeff moved to Westerville July, 1967, the year of Israel's six day war.
Netanyahu has new chance for peace
ALSO IN OPINION
Subscribe to The Dispatch
Sign up for home delivery of The Columbus Dispatch and find out What's In It for You.
While incumbents around the world are struggling to hold on, one is thriving. By bringing the rival Kadima party into his ruling coalition, Benjamin Netanyahu has become “king of Israel,” in Middle East analyst Aaron David Miller’s phrase. He has an unusual, perhaps unique, opportunity to use his new power to secure Israel’s future.
Netanyahu’s coalition now commands one of the largest parliamentary majorities in Israeli history. He faces no plausible rival as prime minister. When pushed on the Palestinian issue, Netanyahu often has cited the constraints of his coalition to explain why he had not taken bolder steps toward resolution. But now he has a broad enough base of support — with many moderates — to move toward a peace settlement without endangering his hold on power.
Look beneath the recent war fears, and Israel is in a stronger position than ever. Its per capita gross domestic product rivals Italy’s (at $31,000). Militarily, Israel is the region’s superpower, with an armed force that could easily defeat any of its neighbors. U.S. aid ) enhances its military edge. It also has one of the world’s largest nuclear arsenals, estimated at more than 200 missiles. At home the wall along the West Bank essentially has solved the problem of Palestinian suicide bombing, rendering Israel safer than at any point in its history.
While Iran does pose a threat, that has been systematically exaggerated over the past few years. Many serious Israeli leaders, including several senior members of its military and intelligence establishment, have spoken up about this in an unprecedented manner. Tamir Pardo of Israel’s intelligence agency, Mossad, has said that Iran is not an existential threat. Last month, Army Chief Benny Gantz described the Iranian regime as rational. Mossad’s Meir Dagan has said that an attack on Iran would be ”stupid.” Kadima party head Shaul Mofaz, the new vice prime minister and a former army chief, has said that an Israeli attack on Iran would produce a regional war and accelerate Iran’s nuclear program.
In his passionate and intelligent book The Crisis of Zionism, Peter Beinart observes a distinction between the ethics of weakness and power. If you see yourself as weak, besieged by the world, and as a victim, Beinart argues, you will embrace any policy that allows you to survive, regardless of its impact on others. On the other hand, an ethic of power recognizes that you are strong and must promote your own interests but with some concept of responsibility, as well. Worse, Beinart argues, the obsession with victimhood has prevented people in Israel and the United States from focusing on the gravest threat to Israel’s existence as a Jewish and democratic state: demography. If there is no progress toward a two-state solution, at some point Israel will not be able to continue to rule over millions of Palestinians without giving them the right to vote — at which point it will cease to be a Jewish state.
In the past, Netanyahu has fiercely embraced the ethic of survival. For decades he has argued that Israel was in imminent danger of extinction, making comparisons to the Nazi threat to Jews in 1938. Long opposed to a Palestinian state, he railed in 1993, when Yitzhak Rabin and Peres signed the Oslo accords, that Peres, then foreign minister, was “worse than (Neville) Chamberlain.” In the book Netanyahu, published that year, he argued that dismantling Jewish settlements would produce a “Judenrein” West Bank (“free of Jews,” a phrase the Nazis used). When he reissued his book several years ago, those phrases were still in the text. Since then, perhaps recognizing the demographic dangers to Israel, he has said he now supports a two-state solution, but he has done nothing to move toward it.
Israel faces real dangers. It sits in a hostile neighborhood, with anti-Semitism rising. Obstacles to Israel-Palestinian peace include the weakness of Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas and radicalism from the terror group Hamas. But a politician of Netanyahu’s skill can find ways to navigate this terrain. The larger questions are: Does he see an opportunity to become a truly great figure in Israeli history? Can he use his power for a purpose other than his own survival?
Fareed Zakaria writes for the Washington Post Writers Group.
comments@fareedzakaria.com
Email
Comments
Login or register to post a comment.
- Advertisement
- Place an ad
FROM THE DISPATCH BLOGS
MINOR DETAILS
McAllister returns to Indians
Espino up from AkronBLOGGING THE BUCKEYES
Andrew Sweat decides not to pursue NFL career
Former Ohio State linebacker Andrew Sweat, who signed as a free agent with the...THE E-TEAM
School-board member has paid $245 for deputy
The cost that Olentangy school-board member Adam White paid to send a sheriff's...THE DAILY BRIEFING
AG Mike DeWine wants Hollywood to kick the smoking habit in youth films
The butt should be banned in movies that kids can see, those rated G, PG and PG-13, Ohio AG Mike...COVERING THE CREW
Pitch Talk: FC Dallas
The Crew and FC Dallas are both hoping to break respective five-game...THE E-TEAM
United Nations Ambassador to address OSU grads
Ohio State University finally announced this week it's spring commencement...THE DAILY BRIEFING
Ohio has Commodores. Who knew?
David T. Daniels, the director of the Ohio Department of Agriculture, is Ohio's newest...REGULAR JOE
Firing (and misfiring) the cannon
- Advertisement
- Place an ad
© 2012 The Dispatch Printing Company, reproduction prohibited. All Rights Reserved.
